Adonis Diaries

Proto-Nazi “Aryan” construction? Mixing Teutons and Greeks

Posted on: July 13, 2015

Proto-Nazi “Aryan” construction? Mixing Teutons and Greeks

Nassim Nicholas Taleb posted this July 12, 2015

GREECE, GREXIT, and “EUROPE” as an unnatural proto-Nazi “Aryan” construction, or why putting Teutons and Greeks together isn’t the smartest (and most stable) idea.

Nor is it natural.

The least *unnatural* union for Greece is some sort of *loose* Mediterranean League of City States (and another minor Balkan connection).

But again, it would need to stay fuzzy –i.e., should you want to use history/culture, use them properly (“annales” style).

There are two natural cultural (eventually leading by mixing to ethnic) demarcations: butter vs olive oil (and eventually a third, the palm tree).

The demarcation is robust: if people have the same food, they are the same (or eventually through mixing) become the same.

Now if a non blind but deaf Martian visited Turkey and Greece, he would think they are the same people (same with Lebanon and Western Syria, all the way to the Euphrates River).

If words are different, body language in the Levant, Greece, Turkey and Southern Italy is similar.

“Una faccia, una razza”.

But a bureaucrat blinded by constructions would put the Greek in the same unit as the German, and bundle the Turk with the Huns in the Altai mountains near China.

But Mediterranean people are integrated as a socio-cultural unit. This is not just recent; the integration is 5000 years old in the East and 3000 in the West.

The trend to “Europeanize” came with German scholarship which starting in 1820s (one Müller) tried to kill any Levantine/Babylonian connection to Greece, trying to give Germany some nobility in its historical roots, while French scholarship was until then considering Greece as deeply rooted in the Levant and Asia Minor, as a continuum from Babylon to the Phoenicians to classical Greece

(Mythology says that Europa herself was Phoenician, at least around the coastal seashores).

The rise of anti-semitism played a part: the Teutonic cultural separation from the Levantine Canaanite race (the Jews and Phoenicians had near-identical language and ethnicity). 

The Levant and what is now Greece spent at least 1000 years in the same political unit Rome-Byzantium and another few hunded in the Ottoman Empire;

 The Greeks and the Germans have now about 40 years together (mostly under occupation).

The nation-state started integrating the Mediterranean people.

During the 19th Century only a few coastal cities such as Marseille and Toulon in Southern France spoke French, the rest spoke Provencal or Catalan.

The idea of a Mediterranean unit is not popular. Partly because it has been linked to Mussolini.

The Mycenians did not use a Semitic language (linear B). But the word Knossos (the capital) means “settlement” in Phoenician.

If a French person looks like a Mediterranean and speaks French, it is by colonization.

The same applies to the “Aryanization” of Greece, to the “Turkification” of Asia Minor, and the “Arabization” of Syria or the “Aryanization” of India.

Arian/Semitic/Hun is not a distinction beyond the language spoken.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s




July 2015

Blog Stats

  • 1,508,637 hits

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by

Join 820 other followers
%d bloggers like this: