Adonis Diaries

Overvaluing confidence in our specific professional knowledge? What kinds of power in humility?

Posted on: August 13, 2016

Overvaluing confidence, we’ve forgotten the power of humility

Information is Not knowledge

Jacob Burak is the founder of Alaxon, a digital magazine about culture, art and popular science, where he writes regularly. His latest book is How to Find a Black Cat in a Dark Room (2013).

If I only had a little humility, I’d be perfect,’ the media mogul Ted Turner supposedly said sometime in the 1990s, in a moment of narcissistic exuberance.

While Turner has been much humbler since, today’s breed of tech entrepreneurs often display a similar arrogance.

Why be humble? After all, Aristotle said: ‘All men by nature desire to know.’

Intellectual humility is a particular instance of humility, since you can be down-to-earth about most things and still ignore your mental limitations.

Intellectual humility means recognising that we don’t know everything – and what we do know, we shouldn’t use to our advantage. Instead, we should acknowledge that we’re probably biased in our belief about just how much we understand, and seek out the sources of wisdom that we lack. (keep experimenting about any thing that people conform with?)

The internet and digital media have created the impression of limitless knowledge at our fingertips.

But, by making us lazy, they have opened up a space that ignorance can fill.

On the Edge website, the psychologist Tania Lombrozo of the University of California explained how technology enhances our illusions of wisdom.

She argues that the way we access information about an issue is critical to our understanding – and the more easily we can recall an image, word or statement, the more likely we’ll think we’ve successfully learned it, and so refrain from effortful cognitive processing.

Logical puzzles presented in an unfriendly font, for example, can encourage someone to make extra effort to solve them. Yet this approach runs counter to the sleek designs of the apps and sites that populate our screens, where our brain processes information in a deceptively ‘smooth’ way.

What about all the commenting and conversations that happen online?

your capacity to learn from them depends on your attitudes to other people. Intellectually humble people don’t repress, hide or ignore their vulnerabilities, like so many trolls.

In fact, they see their weaknesses as sources of personal development, and use arguments as an opportunity to refine their views.

People who are humble by nature tend to be more open-minded and quicker to resolve disputes, since they recognise that their own opinions might not be valid.

The psychologist Carol Dweck at Stanford University in California has shown that if you believe intelligence can be developed through experience and hard work, you’re likely to make more of an effort to solve difficult problems, compared with those who think intelligence is hereditary and unchangeable.

Intellectual humility relies on the ability to prefer truth over social status. ( How can we ever replace the term Truth with an alternative term that has Not this abstract connotation?)

It is marked primarily by a commitment to seeking answers, and a willingness to accept new ideas – even if they contradict our views.

In listening to others, we run the risk of discovering that they know more than we do. But humble people see personal growth as a goal in itself, rather than as a means of moving up the social ladder. We miss out on a lot of available information if we focus only on ourselves and on our place in the world.

At the other end of the scale lies intellectual arrogance – the evil twin of overconfidence.

Such arrogance almost always stems from the egocentric bias – the tendency to overestimate our own virtue or importance, ignoring the role of chance or the influence of other people’s actions on our lives.

This is what makes us attribute success to ourselves and failure to circumstance. The egocentric bias makes sense, since our own personal experience is what we understand best. It becomes a problem when that experience is too thin to form a serious opinion, yet we still make do with it.

Studies have shown that people find it difficult to notice their own blind spots, even when they can identify them easily in others.

From an evolutionary perspective, intellectual arrogance can be seen as a way of achieving dominance through imposing one’s view on others.

Meanwhile, intellectual humility invests mental resources in discussion and working towards group consensus.

The Thrive Center for Human Development in California, which seeks to help young people turn into successful adults, is funding a series of major studies about intellectual humility.

Their hypothesis is that humility, curiosity and openness are key to a fulfilling life.

One of their papers proposes a scale for measuring humility by examining questions such as whether people are consistently humble or whether it depends on circumstances. Acknowledging that our opinions (and those of others) vary by circumstance is, in itself, a significant step towards reducing our exaggerated confidence that we are right.

In the realm of science, if necessity is the mother of invention, then humility is its father.  (Survival of the mother’s necessities are more important than that of the father?)

Scientists must be willing to abandon their theories in favour of new, more accurate explanations in order to keep up with constant innovation.

Many scientists who made important findings early on in their careers find themselves blocked by ego from making fresh breakthroughs.

In his fascinating blog, the philosopher W Jay Wood argues that intellectually humble scientists are more likely to acquire knowledge and insight than those lacking this virtue. Intellectual humility, he says, ‘changes scientists themselves in ways that allow them to direct their abilities and practices in more effective ways’.

Albert Einstein knew as much when he reportedly said that ‘information is not knowledge’.

Laszlo Bock, Google’s head of people operations, agrees. In an interview with The New York Times, he said that humility is one of the top attributes he looks for in candidates, (except in negotiation skills?) but that it can be hard to find among successful people, because they rarely experience failure.

Without humility, you are unable to learn,’ he notes. A little ironic, perhaps, for a company that has done more than any other to make information seem instant, seamless, and snackable.

Perhaps humility’s the sort of thing you can have only when you’re not aware of it.


1 Response to "Overvaluing confidence in our specific professional knowledge? What kinds of power in humility?"

Reblogged this on canisgallicus and commented:
‘Without humility you cannot learn’. This depends on what you want to learn.
Traumatic brain injury over 20 yrs ago with an amnesia void which makes life basically 10 steps (5 x 2) my everyday ie groundhog day life, yes, this article is really captivating for a person like me. TBI teaches you humility because that data information bank that pre accident is stored in your head is deleted and Brocas throws together random words in the hope that you create a sentence in sequence that consolidates a point which really it is impossible to consolidate. Humility is where you have to start. The reality is you have to become an open book and the good part of this perceived tragedy is you can have very fulfilling interaction with people at all levels including virtual. Adonis, daily I read your postings. I know before I start the content is obliterated and I cannot memorise any of it or even the points but what I can do is at a much deeper level, I tap into your humility, your interest in basic human rights, your compassion. In my crazy head I have this belief that technology has made people lazy but if so, for people with disabilities, it has been about empowerment and creating the ‘Level Playing Field’ that leads to education, tolerance and hopefully Equality.
Social media is part of my groundhog day routine. I use Twitter to augment my memory; taking a quote from the vast source of data provided by technology and just passing on a message by a means that 10 years ago did not exist. I believe the term in the US ‘Augmented memory’. WordPress is my latest connection with the world beyond the Groundhog Day. I am humbled that through Twitter and WordPress – a mere person like me can be endorsed by others.
Quote Today
“Let us not deceive ourselves; we must elect world peace or world destruction” Bernard M. Baruch 1870’s US Stockbroker et al

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s




Blog Stats

  • 1,133,669 hits

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by

Join 577 other followers

%d bloggers like this: