Request comment on my article: Hussein-karbala-ashura-shias-ayatollah-marjaa-wilayat-fakih
You may read https://adonis49.wordpress.com/2010/11/03/hussein-karbala-ashura-shias-ayatollah-marjaa-wilayat-fakih/ in order to understand the context.
It was mainly historical accounts of stories that the Moslem Shias believe to be valid and true.
Hussein sent me a “request” comment. His English is poor and I had to edit the text. It says:
“Salaam.
I am a student of Kashmir university. We are 80 students in the class. I am the Only (Moslem) shia out of 80 students (Sunnis?)
I am facing lots of problems when students ask me about shia religion. Sir, I have very few books on the shia religion. I can’t download shia books from internet because i have no computer.
I belong to a poor family, and I have no jobs right now, and I cannot afford to buy books.
Shia books are not available on the market. I have great interest to read shia books in order to “save own self family and save other shia friends“.
Sunni persons are distributing Sunni books for free, every month to us, but I can’t take these books.
Please if you want to save shia community from present challenge then do this great job. God will help you and give strength to save shia persons.
Thanks a lot for reading my words, which are coming from my heart.”(End of quote)
(Saudi Arabia absolute wahhabi monarchy has been publishing since 1980 millioms of Coran (their own version) and distributing them for free in the Moslem World, and appointing their wahhabi preachers in Mosques they constructed…)
Hussein forwarded his mailing address…
My reply:
“Hi Hussein, thanks for your comment.
First, I am not a religious person and don’t care to tell anyone “what is my religion”: It is a private matter.
Second, I don’t deal with dispatching religious books or disseminating religious dogmas and doctrines…
Third, I have published many articles on Shia Moslem sect. You may scroll through the category “religion/history” and locate what might be of interest.
Fourth, I might write an article related to your request”.
Hussein is conveying the following problems:
First, he is the black Shia among the overwhelming white Sunni sheep
Second, he feels isolated and cornered because he cannot engage in religious debate. Why?
He lacks the necessary Shia books, or the proper sources for “truth“?
Third, he is jealous that the Sunni students are receiving free religious book, which he refuses to read. Why? Beats me.
Fourth, the students are practically ignorant concerning the context and content for their arguments. Why engage in such futile discussions?
Fact is, what the Sunni students are getting for free are the religious versions of the Wahhabi Saudi most obscurantist and extremist brand of Islamic sects.
Saudi Arabia absolute monarchy has been printing fabricated “Shariaa” rules and laws focusing on hundreds of ways to controlling, cowing, taming, and subduing women in patriarchal social structures.
Actually, Saudi Arabia hijacked Egyptian, Pakistani, and Afghanistan societies in the last three decades. Saudi Arabia has been exporting its brand of Islam by building mosques, funding religious schools by pouring $billion, and hiring imams converted to their Wahhabi brand of sect.
Saudi Arabia is pursuing its expansionist religious policy and funding Sunni salafist, extremist terrorist factions. Why?
In order to circumvent and confront “Iran Shia influence in the region“?
But Saudi Arabia had this policy before Iran constituted any potential threat in the early 80’s.
Saudi Arabia has to invent a better excuse to explaining why it is still funding terrorist factions in the region, even after the 9/11/2001 attack on the Twin Towers, and going all the way into Mauritania, Mali, Nigeria, and Niger in Africa.
The various differences among Islam sects are not based on the Koran, at least not in the initial verses of the first 13 years of Muhammad message in Mecca.
The initial verses, before the establishment of Islam City-State in Medina didn’t approach the vested political and economic bases of people in the Arabic peninsula.
The main differences are generated by later political rush for power.
Most of the disagreements originate from the Hadith, or the stories and tales of supposed witnesses of Muhammad’s behavior and saying, outside the verses. Thousands of those hadiths were fabricated by successive Califs in order to maintain their hold on power.
For example, who is the legitimate successor of Muhammad?
Should he be exclusively from the tribe of Kuraich in Mecca? Should he be a direct descendant of Muhammad?
For example, should Islam be centralized or should clerics not engage directly in politics and political decision making?
The Hadith was the source of most of the restrictions on women, who were free to express their opinions, write specific contracts for marriage and inheritance, and who were not obligated to wear the veil during Muhammad’s life, except his 8 wives just not to be recognized and disturbed once they are in public…
Note 1: I would tell Hussein:
There is priority in knowledge acquisition.
First knowledge is to learn to be happy.
Second knowledge is to learn to spread happiness in the community: Happiness is very contagious.
Third knowledge is to apply and practice the secret to happiness “Process one idea at a time, then resolve one idea at a time”.
Fourth, learn not to engage in religious discussions and avoid to be drawn into such kind of discussions at this early stage: Abstract concepts that cannot be confirmed or refuted are waste of time, energy, and degenerate into aggravation.
Fifth, learn sciences (natural sciences and social sciences…) so that you may discuss on rational grounds and learn from communicating with professionals… The least interesting knowledge is religion: It is superfluous at a young age, and faith is a matter of personal experiences.
If Hussein comprehends that he is not losing on anything by not receiving any religious books at this stage, he will be far happier and more successful than the remaining 80 students.
Note 2: I suggest to Hussein to refrain from engaging in religious discussions: The end result might turn out to an eventual sort of lynching…
Note 3: Hussein, you may read this post https://adonis49.wordpress.com/2011/09/11/part-1-genesis-of-hezbollah-in-lebanon-accounts-of-robert-fisk/
Like this:
Like Loading...
Adonis Diaries 
Request comment on my article: Hussein-karbala-ashura-shias-ayatollah-marjaa-wilayat-fakih/
Posted by: adonis49 on: September 15, 2011
Request comment on my article: Hussein-karbala-ashura-shias-ayatollah-marjaa-wilayat-fakih
You may read https://adonis49.wordpress.com/2010/11/03/hussein-karbala-ashura-shias-ayatollah-marjaa-wilayat-fakih/ in order to understand the context.
It was mainly historical accounts of stories that the Moslem Shias believe to be valid and true.
Hussein sent me a “request” comment. His English is poor and I had to edit the text. It says:
“Salaam.
I am a student of Kashmir university. We are 80 students in the class. I am the Only (Moslem) shia out of 80 students (Sunnis?)
I am facing lots of problems when students ask me about shia religion. Sir, I have very few books on the shia religion. I can’t download shia books from internet because i have no computer.
I belong to a poor family, and I have no jobs right now, and I cannot afford to buy books.
Shia books are not available on the market. I have great interest to read shia books in order to “save own self family and save other shia friends“.
Sunni persons are distributing Sunni books for free, every month to us, but I can’t take these books.
Please if you want to save shia community from present challenge then do this great job. God will help you and give strength to save shia persons.
Thanks a lot for reading my words, which are coming from my heart.”(End of quote)
(Saudi Arabia absolute wahhabi monarchy has been publishing since 1980 millioms of Coran (their own version) and distributing them for free in the Moslem World, and appointing their wahhabi preachers in Mosques they constructed…)
Hussein forwarded his mailing address…
My reply:
“Hi Hussein, thanks for your comment.
First, I am not a religious person and don’t care to tell anyone “what is my religion”: It is a private matter.
Second, I don’t deal with dispatching religious books or disseminating religious dogmas and doctrines…
Third, I have published many articles on Shia Moslem sect. You may scroll through the category “religion/history” and locate what might be of interest.
Fourth, I might write an article related to your request”.
Hussein is conveying the following problems:
First, he is the black Shia among the overwhelming white Sunni sheep
Second, he feels isolated and cornered because he cannot engage in religious debate. Why?
He lacks the necessary Shia books, or the proper sources for “truth“?
Third, he is jealous that the Sunni students are receiving free religious book, which he refuses to read. Why? Beats me.
Fourth, the students are practically ignorant concerning the context and content for their arguments. Why engage in such futile discussions?
Fact is, what the Sunni students are getting for free are the religious versions of the Wahhabi Saudi most obscurantist and extremist brand of Islamic sects.
Saudi Arabia absolute monarchy has been printing fabricated “Shariaa” rules and laws focusing on hundreds of ways to controlling, cowing, taming, and subduing women in patriarchal social structures.
Actually, Saudi Arabia hijacked Egyptian, Pakistani, and Afghanistan societies in the last three decades. Saudi Arabia has been exporting its brand of Islam by building mosques, funding religious schools by pouring $billion, and hiring imams converted to their Wahhabi brand of sect.
Saudi Arabia is pursuing its expansionist religious policy and funding Sunni salafist, extremist terrorist factions. Why?
In order to circumvent and confront “Iran Shia influence in the region“?
But Saudi Arabia had this policy before Iran constituted any potential threat in the early 80’s.
Saudi Arabia has to invent a better excuse to explaining why it is still funding terrorist factions in the region, even after the 9/11/2001 attack on the Twin Towers, and going all the way into Mauritania, Mali, Nigeria, and Niger in Africa.
The various differences among Islam sects are not based on the Koran, at least not in the initial verses of the first 13 years of Muhammad message in Mecca.
The initial verses, before the establishment of Islam City-State in Medina didn’t approach the vested political and economic bases of people in the Arabic peninsula.
The main differences are generated by later political rush for power.
Most of the disagreements originate from the Hadith, or the stories and tales of supposed witnesses of Muhammad’s behavior and saying, outside the verses. Thousands of those hadiths were fabricated by successive Califs in order to maintain their hold on power.
For example, who is the legitimate successor of Muhammad?
Should he be exclusively from the tribe of Kuraich in Mecca? Should he be a direct descendant of Muhammad?
For example, should Islam be centralized or should clerics not engage directly in politics and political decision making?
The Hadith was the source of most of the restrictions on women, who were free to express their opinions, write specific contracts for marriage and inheritance, and who were not obligated to wear the veil during Muhammad’s life, except his 8 wives just not to be recognized and disturbed once they are in public…
Note 1: I would tell Hussein:
There is priority in knowledge acquisition.
First knowledge is to learn to be happy.
Second knowledge is to learn to spread happiness in the community: Happiness is very contagious.
Third knowledge is to apply and practice the secret to happiness “Process one idea at a time, then resolve one idea at a time”.
Fourth, learn not to engage in religious discussions and avoid to be drawn into such kind of discussions at this early stage: Abstract concepts that cannot be confirmed or refuted are waste of time, energy, and degenerate into aggravation.
Fifth, learn sciences (natural sciences and social sciences…) so that you may discuss on rational grounds and learn from communicating with professionals… The least interesting knowledge is religion: It is superfluous at a young age, and faith is a matter of personal experiences.
If Hussein comprehends that he is not losing on anything by not receiving any religious books at this stage, he will be far happier and more successful than the remaining 80 students.
Note 2: I suggest to Hussein to refrain from engaging in religious discussions: The end result might turn out to an eventual sort of lynching…
Note 3: Hussein, you may read this post https://adonis49.wordpress.com/2011/09/11/part-1-genesis-of-hezbollah-in-lebanon-accounts-of-robert-fisk/
Share this:
Like this: